Turkey Dagwood Sandwich - © comfortcooking.com

Behold! American’s Surprising Top Protein Source

3.0 min. read

‘Protein source’ may be a misnomer in this case. But ‘source’ literally means ‘where something comes from’. And that suits the context perfectly. And I guarantee you’ll be surprised when you learn what America’s top protein source is!

Reuben Sandwich - © allrecipes comA big, beautiful Reuben Sandwich: A mountain of meat, cheese
and classic cabbage slaw, on classy pinwheel rye bread…

There’s a war raging in the test kitchens and nutrition labs across he civilized world. It’s about pro-tein, and how much is enough. And whether you can have too much. And how you should get your protein. I come down on the side of science…

Equal to a feast

There’s an old saying that perfectly describes the clinical world’s warnings about protein consumpt-ion: ‘Enough is equal to a feast!’

And that’s exactly the essence of the scientific and nutritional opinion on protein. The fact is, most of us get all the protein we need every day – often more – from the foods we ordinarily eat. We go over-board on animal protein. Some of us consume more than twice the protein we need – much more than our bodies can process – on any given day. The excess is just broken down and flushed out the other end.

So… Why ‘protein maxxing’?

In stark contrast to the clinical reality, many ordinary folks are mimicking high performance athletes and body builders, eating more high-protein foods and even adding protein concentrates to other foods they regularly consume. Smoothies are the worst culprit. But the unsuspecting masses are also being bombarded with new ‘functional’ foods and beverages featuring added protein. They’re sup-posed to be healthier…

You’re just wasting your precious food money and making the food moguls richer by eating more than 3 to 4 oz / 85 to 115 g of beef or chicken or pork at a sitting. But we’ve been conditioned by tradition and what’s offered on restaurant menus, to consume much more. The best example – one I always cite – is the abiding notion that a ‘small’ steak is 6, or even 8 oz. / 170, or even 225 g. The popular perception is totally disconnected from reality!

But there is one surefire way to get the right amount of protein per serving. And many of us do get it that way. The secret is to enjoy it in a sandwich!

The leading source

Sandwiches, it turns out, are the most popular way Western diners get their protei9n. Be it a burger, a sub, a club, or just a PB&J, a sandwich is something we all default to by habit and tradition. At the same time, sandwiches are apparently becoming even more popular as the younger generations – who value quick service and convenience – come into their own.

A new report from no less an authority than the US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) reveals that sandwiches of all kinds are the single most popular source of protein for adults, making up 15.6 percent Americans consume every day.

The CDC admits a wide range of sandwich types to its assessment, including burgers, deli meat sandwiches, chicken sandwiches, and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, which helps explain their dominance over plated poultry and other common protein sources.

“I can think of many patients of mine who eat at least two sandwiches a day,” says Mary Mosquera Cochran, RD, a registered dietitian at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center. Which she says is okay.

By the numbers…

The CDC analyzed data collected from August 2021 through August 2023 via the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). Participants were asked to recall what they ate over two 24-hour periods. The analysis included 49 categories of foods. The Top 5 protein sources turned out to be:

  • Sandwiches – 15.6 percent
  • Poultry – 9.4 percent
  • Mixed Meat dishes – 6.4 percent
  • ‘Meat’ – 6.0 percent
  • Mixed Grain dishes – 4.8 percent

I’ll admit I was surprised to see sandwiches come out on top. But I was no less amazed to see ‘Mixed Grains’ make the Top 5 at all. The latter statistic makes it clear that many ordinary folks are exploring plant proteins, or at least adding more whole grains to their diets. And that’s a good thing…

My take

As I say over and over again in this space, we’re all going to have to get used to the idea of including more plant protein in our diets as the Meat Age fades into cultural history.

As ‘real’ meat becomes more and more a boutique specialty, and cultured meats become a daily real-ity, we’ll all turn to plant proteins such as beans and ancient grains for sustenance. And it’s good to see a sizeable move in that direction, before it becomes a necessity rather then the current option…

~ Maggie J.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *